One of the largest military company in the world. Develops missile systems consistently used by the Israeli air force against Palestinian civilians; provides drones and radars used to monitor the US-Mexico border; and develops databases and systems for Homeland Security to profile, surveil and monitor immigrant communities.
Northrop Grumman is a U.S.-based defense technology company that develops and manufactures manned aircraft, high-energy laser systems, surveillance and reconnaissance systems (C4ISR), radar, electronic warfare systems, missile systems, and training and logistics support. In 2017, it was the fifth largest arms–producing and military services company in the world and the third largest government contractor in the United States. Northrop Grumman made $25.8 billion in total sales in 2017, of which 85 percent came from U.S. Government sales and 13 percent came from international customers and Foreign Military Sales.
Sale of Weapons to Israel
Northrop Grumman provides the Israeli military with the Longbow system for Apache AH64D helicopters. The Longbow system, a joint venture with Lockheed Martin, consists of the Longbow Hellfire missile (AGM-114L) and a fire-control radar (AN/APG-78). The company also produces key parts for the F-35, a fighter jet manufactured by Lockheed Martin that Israel acquired through the United States government’s Foreign Military Sales program. Northrop Grumman produces approximately 35% of the Lockheed Martin F-35 aircraft, including its center fuselage, radar, avionics, electro-optics, navigation, communications and identification subsystems, and mission systems and mission-planning software. The company also manages pilot and maintainer training systems software as well as the team’s use, support, and maintenance of low-observable technologies. Northrop Grumman also makes the AN/APG-68(V)9 Multimode Fire Control Radar for the F-16.
Northrop Grumman Italia provided the Israeli Air Force with its LISA-200 Attitude Heading Reference System (AHRS) for a fleet of M-346 advanced trainer aircrafts. The company manufactured and provided Israel with its Sa’ar 5 Eilat Class corvettes, which are missile ships used to enforce the siege of Gaza.
Cooperation with the Israeli Military Industry
Northrop Grumman has partnered with various Israeli military corporations and government industries. In 2002, the company signed a 23-year, $487 million deal to provide the U.S., Israel, and 15 other countries with F-16 fire-control radar engineering services, replacement parts, and technical support. In 2003, Northrop Grumman and Israel Aerospace Industries’ TAMAM Division signed an agreement to cooperate in the development of electro-optical payloads for “intelligence, surveillance, targeting and reconnaissance for specified business opportunities.” In 2007, Northrop Grumman announced that it had teamed up with Israel Aerospace Industries (IAI) to build surveillance satellites for the U.S. government. Based on IAI’s TECSAR radar imaging satellite, the spacecraft “Trinidad” captures high resolution images at 400 to 800 kilometers of altitude through its Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) sensor.
In 2007, Stark Aerospace, a subsidiary of Israel Aerospace Industries International, opened a facility in Mississippi. Stark Aerospace manufactures the Hunter Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) for Northrop Grumman. The United States military began using Hunter drones in the 1990s, when IAI and Northrop Grumman won an initial production contract to develop seven Hunter systems. Some Hunter UAVs feature Viper Strike laser guided munitions produced by Northrop Grumman.
In 2008, the company initiated a formal partnership with the government-owned Israeli Aerospace Industry (IAI) to outfit Israeli combat aircraft with radar and missile-firing capabilities.
Northrop Grumman has worked in conjunction with the Israeli military industry to develop a surveillance satellite spacecraft called “Trinidad,” the Hunter Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV), and the LITENING targeting pod--a weapons laser navigation system developed jointly with Rafael Advanced Defense Systems that Israel uses primarily on F-16 aircrafts.
IMI Systems (a subsidiary of Elbit Systems formerly operated by the Israeli state) produces the MPR 500, an advanced warhead compatible with Boeing’s JDAM guiding system. IMI and Northrop Grumman Innovation Systems (previously Orbital ATK) partnered in 2018 to introduce the MPR 500 to the U.S.
Northrop Grumman Weapons Routinely Used against Civilians
F-16 jets, Apache helicopters, and other weapons systems containing parts manufactured by Northrop Grumman have been used repeatedly in Israeli attacks on densely populated civilian areas, resulting in thousands of civilian casualties in Lebanon, the West Bank, and Gaza. The human rights community, including Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International, B’tselem, and United Nations commissions, has ruled these attacks to be human rights violations, collective punishment, and at times war crimes.
Between July 12th and August 14th 2006, Israel conducted a ground and aerial bombardment of Lebanon that severely damaged civilian infrastructure and killed 1,183 people, of whom approximately one third were children. According to a report by Human Rights Watch, Israeli forces fired on civilians and civilian vehicles from Apache helicopters on numerous occasions. Israeli forces deliberately targeted apartment buildings, villages, plants, bridges, seaports, and other key features of Lebanon’s infrastructure. As a result of Israel’s aerial bombardment, over 1 million people were internally or externally displaced. According to a report published by the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (UNOCHA), Israel violated international humanitarian law by failing to take care to prevent civilian casualties during its airstrikes on Lebanese infrastructure.
From December 27th, 2008 to January 18th, 2009, Israel conducted an attack on Gaza it called “Operation Cast Lead” during which Israeli forces used various weapons systems manufactured by Northrop Grumman. According to the UN’s Fact-Finding Mission to the Gaza Conflict, Israel carried out attacks with F-16 aircraft on civilian homes and refugee camps. Missiles fired from Apache helicopters targeted civilians and civilian infrastructure on numerous occasions over the course of the assault. A report by Amnesty International found that Israeli forces used Hellfire missiles produced by Lockheed Martin and Northrop Grumman in their repeated attacks upon clearly marked ambulances and paramedics in uniform. Of the 1,394 Palestinians killed in the “Cast Lead” attacks, 345 were minors. The assault injured over 5,300 people and killed 1,383 Palestinians, of whom 333 were children. Israeli forces destroyed the homes of over 3,400 Palestinian families and left thousands of civilians homeless and physically impaired. According to a report published by the United Nations Human Rights Council, Israeli forces deliberately targeted civilian objects and failed to take every possible precaution to minimize civilian casualties, thereby violating customary international law.
Sa’ar 5 missile ships were used by the Israeli Navy during the 2006 Lebanon war and Operation Cast Lead and are used to enforce the illegal naval siege of the Gaza strip. Israel limits Gaza fishermen to an area no wider than 3 to 6 miles off the coast, severely limiting their access to fishing. The restriction is in contravention of the Oslo Agreements which state that Gaza fishermen should have a clearance of 20 nautical miles off the coast. Even when within the 3 and 6 mile boundaries, Gaza fishermen risk being attacked by Israeli naval vessels, which have killed and injured fishermen and damaged or confiscated their boats. Multiple leading human rights organizations (here, here, and here) consider the siege of the Gaza Strip to be collective punishment in clear violation of Israel’s obligations under international law. In 2016, United Nations Secretary-General Ban Ki-Moon condemned the blockade of Gaza as “collective punishment” and called for accountability. A Sa’ar ship also participated in the Israeli attack on the unarmed Free Gaza Flotilla in 2010, resulting in the killing of 10 humanitarian activists. In November 2017, chief prosecutor of the International Criminal Court Fatou Bensouda reaffirmed that “there is a reasonable basis to believe that war crimes were committed by some members of the Israel Defence Forces” during the attack on the Free Gaza Flotilla in 2010. The Israeli Navy also used Sa’ar ships to enforce a naval blockade on Lebanon during the 2006 Lebanon war.
In 2014, Israel conducted an attack on Gaza called “Operation Protective Edge” that killed 2,251 Palestinians, of whom 1,462 were civilians and 551 were children. Israeli forces used numerous weapons systems manufactured by Northrop Grumman throughout the assault on Gaza. According to a report by Amnesty International, Israel used F-16 aircraft and Apache helicopters during the 2014 assault, including in an attack on Rafah on August 1 and in an attack on Al Shati Refugee camp. Defense for Children International documented at least 13 children killed by missiles fired directly from Apache helicopters in its report on Protective Edge. The Al Mezan Center for Human Rights reported that approximately 47% of civilians killed during “Operation Protective Edge” were killed by warplanes including the F-16. Israeli forces conducted over 6,000 airstrikes in Gaza and damaged or destroyed 18,000 housing units, 73 medical facilities, and many ambulances. As a result of the attack, over 1,500 Palestinian children were orphaned and 11,231 people were injured, of whom 3,436 were children. According to a report by the United Nations Human Rights Council, Israeli forces may have violated international human rights law and committed war crimes on numerous occasions because of their apparent disregard for the preservation of civilian life.
F-16 aircraft were repeatedly used in 2018 to conduct airstrikes in Gaza, resulting in civilian deaths. In February, Israeli missiles launched from F-16 warplanes killed two 17-year-old Palestinian teenagers during six extensive airstrikes, the largest assault since Operation Protective Edge. The attacks wounded two more Palestinians and damaged civilian homes. In July, Israeli forces used F-16 aircraft, helicopters, and unmanned aerial drones to launch about 85 missiles at the Gaza Strip, killing two children and injuring 28 people. The attack damaged residential homes and partially damaged or destroyed numerous ambulances and trucks transporting medical supplies.
U.S.-Mexico Border Surveillance and Cooperation with ICE
With the rise of U.S. border militarization and anti-immigrant policies, Northrop Grumman has offered government agencies technologies to track and monitor the border and individuals, including drones, radars, and advanced biometric database systems.
In 2004, the U.S. Army began patrolling the U.S.-Mexico border with two Hunter UAVs produced by Northrop Grumman and Israel Aerospace Industries (IAI). The same UAVs have also used by the U.S. army in the war in Iraq and Afghanistan to launch laser-guided bombs. In August 2006, Northrop Grumman won a contract from US Customs and Border Protection (CBP) to develop border security surveillance for over 40 ports of entry along the U.S.-Mexico border. The contract involved installing “surveillance, communications, video analytics, network and IT components, and data archival capabilities” at ports of entry as well as training personnel to “identify potential threats at and to ports of entry and collect information through surveillance technologies.”
Ongoing since 2012, CBP uses an airborne radar system developed by Northrop Grumman to track and detain refugees and migrants crossing the U.S.-Mexico Border called VADER, or “Vehicle and Dismount Exploitation Radar”. In 2006, Northrop Grumman won contracts with the US Army to develop VADER, for the intended purpose of tracking “combatants.” Initially used to track insurgents in Afghanistan, the VADER “man-hunting” radar system was adapted to the U.S.-Mexico border. Used for a brief stint on the Arizona border in 2009, VADER became a permanent tool for CBP starting in March 2012. According to CBP, between October 2012 and January 2013 in its first year the radar system helped detain 1,874 people crossing through the Sonora Desert and detected an additional 1,962 people. Since 2012, the VADER system has assisted CBP in detecting over 51,600 people crossing the U.S. Mexico border. Concerns have been raised by the Electronic Frontier Foundation that the surveillance technology has also proliferated to other local and state agencies and is being used for non-border purposes to conduct surveillance on people without probable cause.
In September 2014, Northrop Grumman received a contract from CBP that as of December 2018 has totaled up to $345 million dollars to modernize Customs and Border Patrol’s TECS database which is the platform used by CBP to “decreas[e] the probability of granting access to terrorists, smugglers, or others deemed inadmissible”. CBP uses TECS as a data repository of observations made by CBP agents to “support law enforcement “lookouts,” border screening, and reporting for CBP’s primary and secondary inspection processes.”
Surveillance of Immigrant Communities and Communities of Color
In February 2018, Northrop Grumman received a $95 million dollar contract from the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to develop the first two stages of DHS’ new biometric and biographic database called the Homeland Advanced Recognition Technology (HART) system. The system will be operational by late 2019. Other companies that will be assisting Northrop Grumman with HART system are NEC Corporation who will provide face and iris matching algorithms for HART and Gemalto who will provide fingerprint matching technology. HART is being launched on Amazon Web Services’ Government Cloud.
This system replaces DHS’ old database created in the 1990s, the Automated Biometric Identity System (IDENT), which was used to “identify adversaries” to both “national security and public safety.” Expanding on IDENT’s database of 230 million unique individuals, HART will become one of the largest biometric databases in the world being able to store at least 500 million unique individuals and support at least 720,000 transactions daily. The new HART system will “take critical biometric identity technology to the next level” by cataloguing information about undocumented residents, immigrants and other citizens with their biometric and other personal information. Shared with other government agencies like ICE and CBP as well as state and local law enforcement, HART will hold multiple forms of biometrics- “from face recognition to DNA”. Additionally, DHS plans to use HART to collect information about people’s ‘relationship patterns’ in order to identify “political affiliation, religious activity, and familial and friendly relationships.” HART’s monitoring of ‘relationship patterns’ will include tracking social media behavior and “non-obvious relationships”. The Electronic Frontier Foundation has voiced concerns that this information could be misleading and inaccurate and the “non-obvious relationships” the system identifies could be, “based on nothing more than ‘liking’ the same news article, using the same foreign words, or following the same organization on social media.”
Additionally, the Electronic Frontier Foundation has noted that with mobile biometric devices, HART will allow agencies like ICE and CBP to “identify faces and capture data in the field” allowing agencies to identify and track people in public places without their knowledge or consent. This technology in tandem with tracking political affiliation and religious activity might deter people from exercising their First Amendment rights to political expression and assembly. Another concern is that these systems will disproportionately profile, survey and monitor people of Color, who already are disproportionately represented in criminal and immigration databases. FBI and MIT research has shown that current face recognition systems misidentify people of Color and women at higher rates than whites and men, and that misidentification increases for people with darker skin tones. Current examples of face surveillance technology disproportionately misidentify individuals of color leading critics like the ACLU to raise concerns that HART will encourage racial profiling. DHS’ tests of its own facial recognition system found high levels of inaccuracy and a 2005 Migration Policy Institute study found “42% of [FBI] immigration hits in response to police queries were ‘false positives’.
- On April 9, 2017, Tufts Community Union (TCU) Senate passed a resolution urging the university to divest from "corporations that profit off the occupation of Palestine and the continued spread of settlements declared illegal under international law," including Elbit Systems, G4S, Northrop Grumman, and Hewlett Packard Enterprise.
- On April 12, 2016, the College Council of the University of Chicago passed a resolution to Divest University funds from apartheid, urging the university “ to withdraw, within the bounds of their fiduciary duty, investments in securities, endowments, mutual funds, and other monetary instruments with holdings in companies profiting from human rights abuses and violations of international law in Palestine, including, Northrop Grumman."
- On January 19, 2016, a landslide vote by the University of South Florida student senate passed a joint resolution to divest from corporations who profit from "illegal and brutal occupation" in Palestine, including Northrop Group. The resolution was later vetoed by the student government president.
- In May 2015 the Olgethorpe University Student Senate passed a resolution to divest from Northrop Grumman “based on evidence of their active role in human rights abuses in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.”
- Students at UC Los Angeles passed a resolution to divest from Northrop Grumman in November 2014, stating Northrop Grumman “provide[s] weapons used in attacks on civilians and civilian infrastructure in the Gaza Strip.”
- Wesleyan University’s student senate in 2014 voted to divest the student endowment from Northrop, stating it is “complicit in the illegal occupation of Palestine.”
- In 2013, Canada's York University’s Federation of Students, voted to divest the school’s holdings from Northrop, citing the company’s sale of “weapons and military equipment to Israel.”
- A UC San Diego divestment resolution passed in 2013 stating that Northrop-Grumman “produces the Longbow mast-mounted 360° radar for the Apache AH-64 attack helicopter...used in attacks on the Palestinian population.”
- Students at Canada’s York University Graduate Student Association voted in 2012 to divest from Northrop, citing its role in “Israeli human rights violations, war crimes and oppression.”
- Graduate students at Canada’s Carleton University voted in a 2012 referendum to divest the university’s pension from Northrop-Grumman, citing its involvement in “illegal military occupations and other violations of international law.”
- The University of Michigan Dearborn's student government passed a divestment resolution in 2010 over the company's “...[sale of] weapons, goods, and services to Israel.
- In 2005 and 2006, the University of Michigan at Dearborn's student government passed resolutions urging divestment from Northrop-Grumman, citing the company’s “support and benefit from the ongoing illegal Israeli occupation.”